Welcome to Even Odds Pizza
At Even Odds Pizza, located in Grafton, Wisconsin, pizza is more than just a meal—it's a community experience. Our story begins with a commitment to crafting exceptional, mouthwatering pizzas using fresh, high-quality ingredients. Guests can choose from our hand-tossed or rustic thin-crust options and indulge in a variety of unique toppings and sauces, including our signature Eo sauces. We pride ourselves on providing not just delicious flavors but also a warm, inviting atmosphere where families and friends gather. By actively supporting local causes, we strive to give back to the community that supports us. At Even Odds, it's always about great pizza and good fortune shared.
-
372 Falls Rd, Grafton, WI 53024 Hotline: (262) 376-0420
Welcome to Even Odds Pizza, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Grafton, Wisconsin. Located at 372 Falls Rd, this delightful pizzeria has quickly become a favorite among locals across Ozaukee and Milwaukee Counties. With a commitment to quality and community, Even Odds Pizza isn't just about great pizza; it's a celebration of flavors that takes your taste buds on a journey.
Even Odds Pizza offers a witty fusion of styles, from the renowned Detroit Sicilian Grandma Style, celebrated for its caramelized cheese edges and a succulent blend of olive oil and basil, to the classic American Hand Tossed and Rustic Thin Crust options. Each pizza is baked to perfection, delivering a crispy crust that holds its toppings beautifully—no soggy slices here!
- Toppings Galore: Choose from a distinctive selection, including sauces like Eo pizza sauce and Genovese pesto, paired with fresh vegetables like spinach, jalapenos, and artichokes.
- Cheese Options: Customize your pizza with a delightful array of cheese, from creamy cheddar to tangy feta.
- Meat Lovers: Indulge in a meaty paradise with choices like pepperoni, Italian beef, and even bratwurst!
The highlight of the menu is undoubtedly the Owich Open Faced Pizza Bread, where you can enjoy a hearty serving loaded with double the toppings and cheese, perfect for satisfying any hunger pang.
And speaking of satisfaction, the glowing reviews from patrons speak volumes. Noemi L., an admitted pizza snob from Connecticut, raves about Even Odds Pizza being the closest to her home state's classic pies. Her favorite? The Rustic Thin Crust BBQ Chicken Pizza, which she claims is perfectly topped without crumbling under pressure. It's this attention to quality that has solidified Even Odds Pizza's reputation as a true contender in the local pizza scene.
With a friendly atmosphere and a commitment to community involvement—like participating in local fundraising events—Even Odds Pizza isn't just serving food; they are serving love and connection. Whether you're ordering for a family gathering, a casual evening at home, or a kid's birthday party, you'll find that their pizzas not only taste good but also bring smiles to the faces of those you share them with.
Next time you're craving delicious pizza, remember Even Odds Pizza. With their quick delivery, exceptional service, and, most importantly, a menu that promises flavor and creativity, they are sure to become a staple in your dining rotation. Grab your phone and call them at (262) 376-0420 or head over to their location for a taste of pizza perfection!
Admittedly, I'm a pizza snob. I can't help it, I was born & raised in Connecticut, which happens to be the Pizza Capital of the USA. So trust me when I say that Even Odds Pizza has the BEST tasting pizza pies, not only in Grafton, but all of Ozaukee and Milwaukee Counties. It's seriously the closest thing to the apizzas from back home that I've found outside of CT. Everything, from the dough/crust, sauce, cheese and toppings, are *chef's kiss* delicious. Fresh tasting, cooked perfectly, and they're the only pizza place out here that will cut the pie into TRIANGLE SLICES (as they should be!) and not squares. My favorite Even Odds order is their rustic thin crust BBQ Chicken pizza. They load up on the toppings but you don't have to worry about it falling apart on you. That rustic thin crust is solid and holds up well. No floppy, gloppy crusts here! Their classic hand tossed pizzas are phenomenal, as well. It's the only place that my daughter will eat the crusts from. Another thing about Even Odds that I love is that they're very involved in helping the community. They are involved in all the "Dine to Donate" fundraising events held by local schools, non-profits, and other local programs. If you're considering pizza for any occasion, whether it's a kid's birthday party, employee appreciation party, or casual night at home, consider ordering from Even Odds! You'll be glad you did!
This pizza is amazing. The delivery is great. My pizzas always arrive early and hot! The flavors are great. The ingredients are fresh and abundant. Portions are worth the money! This is a great pizza -- like I remember pizzas tasting when I was a kid. So worth waiting for!!!
Called in a pizza order and got the pizza within 20 minutes! It was fresh and tasty! Thin crust with a nice sauce and plenty of cheese. $13 for a medium with 3 toppings! Two meals for me! Would definitely order again.
Absolutely delicious pizza! Fast and courteous service. This last sentence is just to meet the posting requirement.
The young lady at the counter and taking the orders tonight (don't know her name) was extremely friendly, and courteous. Smiles from the moment I walked in! This person deserves a raise!! Pizza is great also!
Very good pizza, great service and clean place. Prices are not bad and we will be back!
Always have a good experience with Even and Odds! The delivery is great, and how we usually order online. The pizza is delicious every time - we love the meal deal for the variety of Detroit style and pan tossed - so good! And you have to get the cheese sticks!
Always on time. Delivery folks very friendly. Excellent pizza. Buffalo chicken a favorite. Thank you.
We were randomly looking for a pizza place at 9pm on a Monday night in our air bnb. Found this place on yelp and used their website to order. My mom wanted mostly veg and their website was easy to navigate. We added all the veggies and it said a 45 minute wait for delivery. It was maybe a 30-35 minute delivery. Delicious! Fresh! The delivery guy was very nice.